1. Astrology lacks strong proof to support any of its claims.
In This Article...
Is it against the law to believe in horoscopes?
Astrology is the study of celestial body motions and alignments that are thought to have an impact on both the natural world and human affairs. According to historian Emilie Savage-Smith, astrology (also known as ilm al-nujm, “the study of the stars”) was “by far” the most widely used of the “many disciplines aiming to forecast future events or perceive hidden phenomena” in early Islamic history.
Despite Islamic prohibitions, some Muslims in the Middle Ages were interested in studying the apparent motion of the stars. This was due in part to their belief that celestial bodies were necessary, as well as the fact that desert nomads frequently traveled at night and relied on knowledge of the constellations to direct them. The need for Muslims to determine the time of the prayers, the direction the Kaaba should face, and the proper orientation of the mosque after the advent of Islam helped give astronomy a religious impetus and contributed to the idea that celestial bodies had an impact on both terrestrial affairs and human condition.
Islam’s position on astrology is governed by Islamic law, the Quran, the Hadith, the Ijma (scholarly consensus), and Qiyas (analogy). The concept’s classification is further broken down into halal (authorized) and haram (forbidden) categories (forbidden). Astrology is prohibited by the authorities, as stated in the Quran and Hadith, according to all Islamic sects and experts.
Why not believe in astrology?
1. Astrology lacks strong proof to support any of its claims. Astrologers claim that changes in the motion of the planets will cause changes in your personality, however NASA has discovered a great number of planets besides those that are currently known to us.
Some beliefs are basically private, while others have more obvious policy repercussions.
I have less tolerance for prominent academic and media figures who aggressively support junk science when they don’t just express their belief in speculative theories supported by no real data, but then go on the attack against people who point out these emperors’ nudity. In addition, even a hypothetical tolerant, open-minded supporter of junk sciencethe sort of person who might believe in critical positivity ratio but also actively support the publication of criticisms of that workcan still do a certain amount of damage by diluting scientific journals and the news media with bad science, and by promoting sloppy work which reduces space for more careful research.
You know how they say that science is self-correcting, but only because people are willing to self-correct?
Similarly, Gresham’s law is real, but only because people are willing to circulate counterfeit bills, or to circulate money they suspect may be counterfeit, while keeping their mouths shut until they can get rid of their wads of worthless stock.
P.P.S.Just to be clear:No, I don’t know that astrology is a waste of time, and it could be that Marc Hauser was onto something real, even while he was fabricating data (according to the U.S. government, as quoted on Wikipedia), and the critical positivity ratio and ovulation and voting and all the rest . . . all these could be realwho knows!
Just cos there’s no good evidence for a theory, that doesn’t make it false.
I don’t want to suppress any of these claims.
Publish it all somewhere, along with all the criticism of it.
What did Jesus have to say regarding astrology?
I believe that astrology was a tool God created for us to use as a spiritual tool and to better understand ourselves. I think there are numerous scriptural passages that lend credibility to astrology. I concentrate on what Jesus taught as a Christian. When Christ prophesied in Luke 21:25, “There shall be signs in the sun, moon, and stars,” he was referring to the significance of astrology. He talks to the disciples about the significance of astrology and how it might be interpreted as a sign of his coming back. Why would Jesus reveal this crucial information to us if we are not intended to interpret the energies of the planets and signs and if he actually opposed it? Jesus warned us that there will be signals in the sky upon his return, just as the three wise men understood that Jesus would be born under the star in the sky that guided them to him lying in the manger.
Zodiac signs: fact or fiction?
Astrology: Is it true? Although reading horoscopes is a well-liked past time, is there any scientific evidence that it has any significance?
When you are lured by a familiar interruption and your willpower wanes, problems may result.
Up to 70 million Americans consult their horoscopes every day. At least that is what the American Federation of Astrologers claims. A Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life research conducted twenty years ago found that 25% of Americans thought that the positions of the stars and planets had an impact on our daily life. According to the General Social Survey from 2012, 34% of Americans asked think astrology is “extremely” or “kind of” scientific. The percentage of those who think astrology is “not at all scientific” has decreased from two-thirds to roughly one-half.
The concept that astronomical phenomena, such as the stars above when you were born or the fact that Mercury is in retrograde, have the ability to affect the daily happenings in our lives and our personality traits is commonly referred to as astrology. The study of astronomy, which is the scientific study of celestial objects, space, and the mechanics of the cosmos, is obviously very different from this.
An element of astrology in particular that is gaining popularity is the ability to predict one’s future or provide advise on daily actions through horoscopes. Horoscope pages saw a 150 percent spike in hits in 2017 compared to 2016, according to publications like The Cut.
It’s obvious that many individuals are looking for methods of star interpretation. Understanding the locations of the stars, the basis of astrology, seems to be a sufficiently scientific endeavor. But can science support the idea that astrology has an impact on our personalities and our lives?
But since I have you for the remaining five minutes of this six-minute-or-so podcast, let’s examine the precise methods by which astrology has been put to the test.
Can astrology hurt you?
Vyse asserts that horoscopes turn into an issue if they significantly affect your conduct, whether you’re hunting for love or managing your finances.
Other devotees turn to astrology when they must make difficult choices regarding their health. Before scheduling surgery, a New York lady who wished to remain anonymous says she contacts her astrologer. “I have complete faith in it.”
This, according to Vyse, pushes the boundaries of control illusion. He claims that while basing “unimportant judgments” on your horoscope may be entertaining, that is where the line should be drawn. “Making a significant decision based on your horoscope is never a good idea. Why not just toss a coin?”
Because a horoscope only provides at best random information, Sandbek claims that it can be “downright destructive.” He continues by saying that relying on astrology during trying circumstances can prevent personal progress by impeding your capacity to make sensible choices.
Does astrology hold a theistic view?
I’ve been asked to address the compatibility of astrology and religion numerous times over the course of my many years of counseling with deeply religious clients. I have noticed an amazing ideological connection between organized faiths and the ordered cosmos of astrology, despite the fact that some fervently religious people regard the practice of astrology as heretical.
Astrology and strict religious belief are mutually compatible. The idea that God created the universe, in which even the planets and stars are governed by high ideals, is actually a smooth leap.
My position is supported by history, which demonstrates that the study of the planets and stars predates and has influenced religious doctrine and practice all throughout the world. Evidence for this can be found in ancient literature, sculptures, and works of stained glass art. In our earliest historical places of religious devotion, astrological signs and planets are represented by symbols. Significant religious leaders including Jesus, Mohammed, Moses, Buddha, and Mary Baker Eddy all came into existence during times when the stars were aligned in a way that synchronistically confirmed their presence.
It is possible to trace the origins of some fervent religious followers’ resistance to a time when priests and other religious authorities sought to mediate and interpret every religious experience from their positions of authority. Our forefathers sought divine inspiration straight from the stars and believed themselves to be an intricate part of an active universe unfolding before the rise of male-dominated organized religion. A discipline and belief system based on an enchantment with the divine orchestrations of the heavens, astrology was accessible to everyone. Astrology assumes an infinite and purposeful intelligence that penetrates the skies and the earth in a vast symphony of meaning rather than the worship of a single godhead or leader.
The Latin word religio, which means to connect together, is the word’s root. The motions of the skies and the experiences and happenings on Earth are inextricably interwoven.
Through the interpretation of the 9th and 12th houses as well as the archetypes of the planets Jupiter, Saturn, and Neptune, astrology recognizes the significance of religion and spirituality. The 9th and 12th houses represent regions of life where a person may look for spiritual or religious direction, experience, or ordination. Saturn might represent a severe God image, Jupiter can represent a strong spiritual or religious leader, and Neptune can represent mystical encounters and the rapture.
A reputable, objective astrologer can assist a customer in strengthening their ties to their religion. Through an examination of their chart, I have assisted some clients in reclaiming and activating their religious roots, directing them toward the power they can find in following a religious path. For some people, religion is a crucial component of their psychological and mental health.
Contrary to many established religions, astrological activities and beliefs are not burdened by sexism, racism, homophobia, or other forms of oppression. Even the traditional metaphors used in astrology to distinguish between male and female planets and energies have been reinterpreted as receptive and active energies that are non-gendered in their expression. Everybody has a significant seat at the cosmic table, just as every planet and star in the sky has its own place.
astrology and institutionalized religions:
- generating meaning
- are not supported by science
- age tens of thousands of years.
- based on legend and myth
- have produced amazing, creative writing and art
- Make people feel like they belong and have an identity
- Assisting people in overcoming extreme sorrow and loss
- discussion of the concepts of fate and free will
- have a history of group rites
- have calendars for important occasions
Contrary to religion, astrology
- Lacking places of worship
- has no requirements or commitments to join
- possesses no moral laws
- does not make a meritorious superiority claim
- lacks a human saint
- lacks a scale of worthiness
- doesn’t suggest an afterlife
- provides no concrete guidelines for social behavior
- There is no mention of a written agreement requiring training
- has no authorized uniforms or costuming for practitioners
- doesn’t require worship
These lists demonstrate how astrology and religion could work together very effectively.
Religion is a Saturn word in astrological terms because it is structured, spells out right and wrong, and is founded on and on agreements and structures. The occult is more Uranian: