We know that Vedic astrology adjusts the signs for precession, whereas Western astrology preserves every sign at the same time of year regardless of the season. This isn’t to say that Western astrology isn’t accurate or that Vedic astrology isn’t. Because, as we all know, astrology is all about the positions of the planets in the sky, not the signs. The tropical and sidereal zodiacs are both inaccurate in terms of astronomy. The constellations do not form a full 360o circle in the sky, and most (but not all) of the constellations closest to the ecliptic are explained by astrology (despite the reports, there is no 13th sign called Ophiuchus).
The tropical zodiac is more indicative of our material culture and society because it is linked to the seasons and the sun’s rising to summer and descend to winter throughout the year. The sun represents our ego, which tends to take precedence over everything else. The sidereal zodiac is more reflective of our soul’s journey and spiritual path because it corresponds to the stars and the wider backdrop of the cosmos. Neither is more correct than the other, and they both have valid points to make.
In This Article...
Is Vedic astrology more accurate than Tropical astrology?
Between these two astrological forms, there is a variation in the house system. Vedic astrologers utilize whole-sign houses, with the Ascendant’s sign occupying the first house. The four angular houses (1st, 4th, 7th, and 10th) are known as kendras and are the seat of authority in Vedic astrology. The trikonas, on the other hand, hold the areas of good fortune and opportunity (1st, 5th, 9th).
All of these distinctions demonstrate that both of these types of astrology have their unique significance. Western astrology employs a distinct methodology, more akin to an open system, in which conventional procedures for preparing the birth chart are given less weight. Traditional methods, on the other hand, are the foundation of calculation and analogy in Vedic astrology. Because we can’t view the outer planets with our naked eyes, they aren’t utilised here. The best part about Vedic astrology is that planets are directly linked to energizing qualities like yoga, ayurveda, and a slew of other key spiritual assets in India.
Western astrology can produce bizarre results because astrologers here believe on the Sun sign, which is fixed for one month, as opposed to Vedic astrology, which emphasizes the Moon, which is fixed for 2.25 days. Let us have a look at how Vedic astrology differs from Western astrology.
Moon houses aren’t very important in Western Astrology. The Sun is the most important planet here, and its position is accorded great importance. The moon houses, on the other hand, are important in Vedic Astrology. In Vedic astrology, there are 27 Constellations. They are the most important factor in making time-related predictions. It is possible to learn about the finest times in life in order to establish a successful business, purchase a home, or perform ceremonies such as weddings, partnerships, or housewarmings. The Nakshatras are also useful for assessing a person’s characteristics and gaining a thorough understanding of their mental state. While Vedic astrology can provide more precise results by focusing on the moon, western astrology is unable to do so.
Horoscope matching is a valuable feature of Indian Vedic Astrology that has been utilized to determine the compatibility of a potential bride and groom before marriage since ancient times. Horoscope matching, also known as Kundli matching, is a wonderful present for a newlywed couple. The more traits (gunas) that match, the more compatible the bride and groom are. Horoscope matching can easily reveal two people’s potential to operate well together. Such information is not available in Western astrology. Though we can perform compatibility analysis using this method, the results will not be as exact as in Vedic astrology.
Nothing compares to the precision and profundity of Vedic Astrology. Western astrology can’t compete with the Vedic system’s deep levels of wisdom and insight. We employ nakshatras in Vedic astrology to refine the meaning and expression of the chart. The time-systems analyze the signals and themes of your current existence (dashas). There are dozens of aspects (Vargas) that can assist you in extracting the intricacies of every area of your life, from marriage to death, and from happy to terrible times. Western astrology, on the other hand, relies heavily on the sun for predictions and progression, which has rendered their method ineffective for many years.
Finding a good muhurta is highly crucial in Vedic astrology while starting any new work. Muhurta is the art of choosing the most auspicious time to achieve success in any endeavor you choose. By regularly studying the cosmic position for the window period to start something new or make any crucial decision, Vedic astrologers compute the auspicious moment. In western astrology, on the other hand, there is no such precise method for determining the optimal time to start a new business.
The composition, alignment, pace, and movement of the current transits are used to foretell the future in western astrology. Western astrology is not very good at predicting events; instead, it focuses on predicting changes in a person’s attitude or how the planets will affect his character. The current planetary phase, or shift in the position of the planets in a person’s birth chart, is used in Vedic astrology to forecast the future. As a result, each planet dominates your home for a specific amount of time. Interestingly, depending on the nature of the ruling planet, that time period might be favorable or harmful. For example, the Sun reigns for six years and Saturn reigns for nineteen. As a result, Vedic astrology’s future predictions are more precise and precise.
Because it is based on more exact astronomical principles, Vedic astrology appears to be more upright than western astrology. The best part about Vedic astrology is that the astrologers consider not just the natal chart but also the dasas, or periods of different planets travelling through different signs, and their impact on people’s lives. In addition, Vedic Astrology places a greater emphasis on the Moon sign than the Sun sign. The reason for this is that the Moon changes signs every 2.25 days, whereas the Sun takes around a month, so predictions based on the Moon are more accurate because our moods and circumstances change frequently. Second, because the moon governs the mind and emotions, predictions and analyses based on the moon’s position are more accurate. Vedic Astrology, in contrast to western astrology, can provide more concrete and detail-oriented ways of prediction.
Planets, signs, and houses are used in both Vedic and Western astrology to produce the chart. Vedic astrology, on the other hand, takes into account “Because it depicts the sign that was rising on the eastern horizon at the very moment you were born, you are the rising sign. This is more precise than using a calculator “In Western astrology, the sun sign is employed to prepare your chart. The reason we say this is because the sun has been in the same sign for the past 30 days. Your rising sign, on the other hand, was thought to be the exact minute on the day you were born. The sun is undeniably significant, but so are the other planets, particularly the moon, when making an astrology chart.
Vedic astrology encompasses astrological gemology, color therapy, mantra therapy, and a slew of other techniques for counteracting the harmful effects of the planets in our life. Western Astrology does not provide such a solution, which is one of the main reasons why western systems cannot match Vedic Astrology’s immense power.
Western astrology focuses on assessing an individual’s psychological nature, although it is ineffective at predicting future events. Vedic astrology, on the other hand, produces more predictable outcomes when it comes to predicting when specific events would occur. Vedic astrology is founded on karma, therefore it accurately describes an individual’s karmic tendencies and when they can be developed to that individual’s benefit. In western astrology, there is no technique for using karma to reap future advantages.
Yearly Vedic astrology predictions are more accurate and reliable than Western astrology predictions. All of these forecasts based on signs are generic. In western astrology, the sun sign is used to predict the year, therefore all people born in the same month are assigned to the same sun sign. They would be inheriting a certain set of traits. However, when utilizing moon signs to make a yearly prediction, two people born in the same month but at different times may have distinct birth stars. This is why Vedic astrology forecasts are more accurate.
You may have questioned why, according to Western astrology, your Sun sign is Aries, but in the Vedic system, it is Cancer. You may also notice differences in your rising sign and the placement of other planets in new signs. This occurs because a horoscope is calculated differently in Vedic and Western astrology. Both employ distinct methodologies to make predictions about a person’s nature, conduct, life events, and major events. Because the Western system is based on the Sun, it is superior at assessing physical and psychological patterns. Because it is based on the lunar system, which has a stable constellation, the Vedic system is considerably better at explaining the soul nature and predicting future occurrences.
Another advantage of the Vedic method over the Western system is that it employs the Dasa Predictive System. Depending on the planet, a planetary Dasa can last anywhere from 6 to 20 years. Vedic astrology not only assesses the circumstance, but also calculates the outcome of karma and offers a remedy to mitigate the bad effects of planets ruling your home. Thus, the Vedic system is more accurate because it has remained intact for thousands of years, and its base is the knowledge employed in modern astronomy with reference to any astronomical phenomena that occur inside the system. Let us be proud of our Vedic system!
Which astrological system is the most accurate?
Although the houses are measured out in 30 degree increments starting from the degree of the ascendant, the ecliptic is divided into twelve divisions of 30 degrees in the equal house method. It starts with the ascendant, which works as the 1st house’s ‘cusp’ or starting point, then the second house begins 30 degrees later in zodiacal order, then the third house begins 30 degrees later in zodiacal order from the second house, and so on. Equal house proponents believe that in higher latitudes (particularly above 60 degrees), it is more accurate and less misleading than the Placidean and other quadrant house systems.
Is it better to use tropical or sidereal time?
The tropical zodiac is based entirely on the sun, with the signs aligned with the ecliptic. The sidereal zodiac is determined by the sun’s position in reference to the constellations as seen in the night sky (measured in the early morning when the sun rises).
Is astrology in China more accurate than astrology in the West?
According to the Feng Shui Institute, although horoscopes in the western zodiac have just 500 permutations of parameters, your Chinese astrological profile might include over 13 million, including your birth year, month, and time, making it considerably more unique to you than a horoscope.
Is Vedic and Sidereal the same thing?
In current times, Vedic astrology is known as sidereal astrology. The main astronomical difference between tropical and sidereal astrology is that they employ distinct timing systems, with Vedic astrology using a sidereal timing method.
Astronomers use the sidereal timekeeping system to keep track of Celestial Objects and their exact positions in the sky.
The term “sidereal” comes from the Latin word “ford sidus,” which meaning “star” or “nakshatra.”
The duration of a sidereal year is the time it takes for the Sun to complete a full round and return to the same location with respect to the star or nakshatra from whence it began.
The length of a sidereal day is 23 hours 56 minutes and 4 seconds to be precise. As a result of the equinox’s precession, the sidereal year is approximately 20 minutes longer than the tropical year.
This disparity is caused by the precession of the Vernal equinox, which implies that the Earth’s rotating axis is progressively changing and takes 25,800 years to complete a full rotation.
Tropical astrology aligns the Northern Hemisphere’s vernal equinox with 0 degrees of Aries, or the Sun’s position at the March equinox. The equinox precession is not taken into account in this system, hence the rest of the zodiac circle is defined from this point.
The sidereal system, on the other hand, defines all zodiac signs as a point relative to the motion of stars caused by the equinox’s precession.
As a result, the two systems drift 1 degree apart every 72 years, because one system accommodates equinox precession while the other does not.
As a result of this disparity, planets’ positions in tropical birth charts have moved away from their real positions in the sky with respect to the stars or nakshatras in modern times.
The difference between sidereal and tropical astrology was extremely slight when tropical astrology was adopted during the Hellenistic period (32332 BC).
As a result, when tropical astrology was first used, the tropical and sidereal zodiacs were practically perfectly aligned.
This also suggests that, at the time, tropical birth chart calculations were nearly in tune with actual star placements.
0 degrees of Aries of the Vernal Equinox (aka First Point Of Aries) corresponds to the real Aries constellation at the moment. In tropical western astrology, however, it no longer correlates due to the equinox’s precession.
The Earth’s axis has wandered to around 6 degrees of Pisces from the Hellenistic period to the present day and age, since the equinox shifts approximately 1 degree every 72 years. By the year 2600, it will have moved to Aquarius.
As a result, the difference today is about 23 degrees, which is about the length of a full sign of 30 degrees.
Many planets on the tropical birth chart are misaligned from their real positions in the sky during the birth, according to all of this information. As a result, the sidereal and tropical birth charts diverge.
The mismatch is repaired in the sidereal birth chart using a unique corrective degree called Ayanamsha.
Ayanamsha Correction
Now, when the birth chart is calculated using a modern calendar that accommodates the tropical year (which is approximately 20 minutes shorter than a sidereal year), there is a conflict with the actual positioning of the Sun and other planets in relation to star positions.
As a result, the planetary positions in a tropical birth chart are out of sync with the real positions of the planets.
The correction degree in Vedic sidereal astrology, on the other hand, automatically synchronizes the current calendar year with an actual cosmic calendar (sidereal solar year).
In Vedic astrology, this is known as Ayanamsha. To be more explicit, during the creation of the birth chart, the most accurate True Lahiri/Chitrapaksha Ayanamsha, which is presently exactly 22.46047 degrees, is inserted, which synchronizes the equinox drift.
As a result, we can calculate the exact position of the planets in relation to actual star positions.
While the equinox continues to shift 1 degree westward every 72 years, the Ayanamsha will ensure that proper sidereal calculations are made.
Ayanamsha can be simply defined as the difference in degree between tropical and sidereal planetary locations, whereas the sidereal is true and represents actual planetary degrees.
For example, if you were born on September 10th, 1994, your true Sun sign is Leo (sidereal), not Virgo (tropical).
This is why the Sun sign in the Vedic sidereal astrology birth chart differs from the Sun sign in the tropical or western astrology birth chart.
Most people born under distinct Sun signs, both tropical and sidereal, may probably relate to the sidereal Sun sign better in terms of character and inner soul.
Vedic Weekday
This also means that a person’s sidereal birthday differs from the date on which he or she is born on the calendar. The actual birthday is known as a Vedic Weekday, and it is significant because each day is ruled by a different planet.
When a person is born on the Vedic weekday of Wednesday, for example, it implies that his or her soul was sent to earth by Mercury or Hermes, which reveals a lot about the native’s soul mission.
Because the zodiac signs differ in both astrological traditions, the attributes of zodiac signs change slightly as well. The qualities of tropical zodiac signs must be altered and changed in accordance with the precession of the equinox, whereas the characteristics of sidereal zodiac signs have remained constant from the dawn of time.
This is why, when reading birth charts in sidereal, it is feasible to rely on ancient texts.
This is also why tropical and Vedic astrology readings are performed differently. Both lead to accurate and precise results, but from quite different perspectives. The planetary lordships and aspects, for example, are radically different in both systems.
It’s also possible to check this with just your eyesight. If you look at the night sky and observe a planet in a precise position with regard to the stars, you’ll notice that your sidereal birth chart has the exact same position as the actual sky, yet your tropical western chart has a different location.
If you don’t know how to identify planets with your naked eye, you can use an astronomical program like Stellarium to examine actual planetary positions and compare them to the Vedic sidereal astrology birth chart for the same date and time you’re looking at the sky.
Astrology, Philosophy & Religion
To begin with, astrology is not and has never been a form of witchcraft because it derives its results from genuine science and physical objects rather than ghosts or magic.
Witchcraft or magic is severely prohibited in religion because it entails going against God’s will by changing the fate of events and individuals. Anything that contradicts the all-powerful God is sinful, and astrologers definitely agree on this.
Instead of finding surrealistic techniques to artificially boost fortune, astrology focuses on actual facts and provides wisdom to deal with reality. Astrology seeks to tell us that everything in this universe works according to God’s will. We can recognize who we are and why we are here by looking at our charts, which will help us align our spirits with God’s will.
Jyotish, or ancient astrology, is based totally on Dharma, or righteousness, which implies it was formed by supreme beings with the help of God and archangels. It was intended to help humanity become enlightened via wisdom and discover the way to Almighty God.
Jyotish, or the science of astronomy, is an important aspect of Vedanga, which is a compilation of Hinduism’s most fundamental teachings. In truth, Hinduism is the world’s oldest religion, dating back to roughly 7000 BCE, and focusing solely on righteousness, much like the religious teachings of all other religions throughout history.
With that in mind, Jyotish, or the study of light or creation, teaches that there is only one source of all beginnings, the almighty God.
As a result, practicing and studying astrology is not considered wicked because it does not include the use of sorcery or witchcraft to change people’s conduct. Astrologers, on the other hand, focus on God’s natural will and employ celestial bodies as a translation of that will.
In other words, astrologers see all natural events, such as planet motions, as a sign from God, indicating the correct and moral path. Furthermore, astrology places a strong emphasis on righteousness and the accomplishment of karma, which is allocated to us by the Almighty God.
Furthermore, Vedic astrology focuses on attaining salvation, or the purest form of the soul, which allows one to enter heaven and return to the one and only creator, almighty God. This demonstrates that Vedic astrology focuses solely on soul purity and justice.
Wisdom is of the greatest worth or benefit. Wisdom has brought tremendous joy and happiness to those who have been endowed with it. This is because wisdom aids us in distinguishing between moral and immoral behavior. As a result, wisdom promotes justice, ethics, and morals.
Meteorologists, for example, predict or precalculate climate and weather conditions in order to assist humanity in preparing and acting appropriately.
Predicting climate calamities such as storms and hurricanes, for example, is critical for community well-being and hence a holy act.
In reality, in medieval times, astronomy and astrology were employed to forecast weather, which was crucial for seafarers.
Birds rely on the stars to navigate in the natural world. When humans rely on stars, which are God’s pure creation, it becomes simpler to find a route to ultimate fulfillment or to reconnect with God by escaping material illusion.
Astrology operates in the same manner that astrologists evaluate the cosmic climate in order to lead people down the right road that is in line with the will of the one and only almighty God.
Vedic sidereal astrology, according to the above, is acceptable for everyone, regardless of cultural background, nationality, or religion.